Site Meter Watching Stargate » Episode Reviews

Episode Reviews

Premiere Paydirt!!!!!

Monday, October 8th, 2007

Weir_season_4.jpg
Torri Higginson

It’s taken me a week just to decide what I had to say about the season 4 premiere of Stargate: Atlantis. Normally, I don’t find myself lacking in words, but this time… all that comes to mind are the same old boring ones. Words like ‘Wow!’ And ‘Holy Crap!’ And ‘Huh?’ So, I find myself reduced to expressing myself in list form, and here goes. If you haven’t seen the ep and don’t want spoilers, don’t read.

1 — Weir is a flipping cyborg!!! I, for one, think that is amazingly cool. While I have always enjoyed her character, she has always lacked a trait that made her stand out from the rest. She could speak Ancient, but so could many others on the Atlantis base. She was a diplomat. Yeah, but how often did she really get to use this ability to good effect? Seldom. Seldom. Teyla’s a fighter, a part Wraith and a local. Ronin is a runner and a local. John is a soldier, has the gene and is an unbelievable pilot. Rodney, well, Rodney’s is Mr. Universal Science with Zelenka as a his sidekick. But Liz? Well, now she has an incredible ability all her own. And if she has to miss much of this season because of the change, that’s ok. I trust to writer’s to bring her back cooler than ever.

2 – Rodney is a genius. Enough said.

3 – The depth of emotion we saw in John and in Ronin during the premiere was truly impressive. I want to see more! Oh, and the Ronin/Weir shippers and Teyla/Weir slasher must have really loved this ep. Hints of everything all around.

4 – I still haven’t warmed up to Jewel Staite as the new doctor. This is ironic since I am a Browncoat through and through. However, the character as written and, unfortunately, performed is a cookie cutter doctor. Except for not wanting the job, she lacks the quirks and idiosyncrasies that make scifi characters interesting.

5 – I loved the entire section with the asteroid field. Especially McKay’s comment that he once scored zero on the game Asteroids. That is just classic McKay. Go, Rodney!

6 – Finally, a mild complaint. What is with Sam’s new hair? I know that Amanda Tapping has wanted long hair for years, but Sam Carter is still bound by military regs. It bothers me. What do you guys think?

Torri_season_4.jpg

If you want to know more about what’s up and coming in season 4, click here.

, , , , , , , , , ,

About Watching Stargate

This site is about "Stargate" - the science fiction media franchise that began in 1994 with the feature film "Stargate". The subsequent body of works detail an elaborate fictional universe where Earth battles hostile aliens possessing superior technology or supernatural powers. The film's story is continued in novel form, in two live-action television series ("Stargate SG-1" and "Stargate Atlantis"), one animated series ("Stargate Infinity"), and in other derivative works.

Watching Stargate Author(s)
    » Catslyn

TV Channel Posts

  • The He in the She - last new episode for a while...
    Let me start by saying... wow. I'm impressed. I'm going to have to give this a little more thought - there was a lot of really interesting points brought up in this episode, and there was so much [...]
  • Heroes Roundup for 10.11.08
    Digital Spy has a short article about Jack Coleman in which he talks about his horn-rimmed glasses: "My character was called Horn-Rimmed Glasses from the start," Coleman told Radio Times. [...]
  • Promo Images from Episode 3.07, “Eris Quod Sum”
    Here are several images from episode 3.07, “Eris Quod Sum.”  Kristen Bell fans will be pleased to see that she is back. Looks like we’ll be seeing a big fight between Elle and the [...]
  • Promo Images from Episode 3.06, “Dying of the Light”
    Here are 3 images from episode 3.06, "Dying of the Light." They show villains Adam Monroe and Knox visiting Arthur Petrelli's bedside. Does that mean the promo that shows Arthur meeting [...]
  • More Promotional Images from Episode 3.05, “Angels and Monsters”
    NBC has been busy releasing promo images for episodes 5, 6, and 7.  In this set, from episode 5, “Angels and Monsters,” we get our first look at villain Stephen Canfield, known as Vortex, as [...]
  • CMT’s Reality Shows
    It looks like CMT is in the Reality TV show business too. CMT’s two hit shows My Big Redneck Wedding and Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders: Making The Team both returned last Saturday. My Big Redneck [...]
  • CMT’s Reality Shows
    It looks like CMT is in the Reality TV show business too. CMT’s two hit shows My Big Redneck Wedding and Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders: Making The Team both returned last Saturday. My Big Redneck [...]
  • Emily Deschanel in Statement Magazine
    GREAT shot of Emily Deschanel from the "Green Issue" of Statement Magazine. I love the caption - considering how we all know how active Emily is in different environmental and animal rights causes. [...]
  • Rebecca Mader in George Clooney Movie
    Lost co-star, Rebecca Mader, is joining George Clooney's latest project, Men Who Stare at Goats. Rebecca will play one of George's leading lady and will be part of an ensemble cast that includes [...]
  • Epsiode 3.2 - Crimes of Fashion Recap
    We are only on the third episode of the season and already it's getting really good. I have to admit that I didn't expect much out of this one since it seemed to center around one plot and [...]

Hot Off The Press